But as a result of failing to properly manage the connections, at least two affiliated councils are seeking legal action and the other is seeking bail for the government to pay its thousands of council employees and suppliers, including the Central Coast Council. On Friday it was suspended and the government appointed an administrator. The Inner West lost its chief executive last week as its finances deteriorated.
LSI Consulting – which has been researching the performance of councils for three decades and providing performance consulting services to councils across the country – said the problems that have arisen in NSW councils in recent weeks are the tip of the iceberg.
“Mismanagement, failure to control costs and a lack of transparency and inefficiency and a misunderstanding of performance and productivity sum up what is going wrong in the councils,” said LSI Chief Ian Bahi.
He said a change was needed not only for the unified councils but also for the councils across the country.
Mr Bahi said the Covid 19 would put more pressure on council funds, which have been higher than inflation in NSW and Victoria for the past decade. “Rates will have to rise because councils have lost so much money. They will have to get money from state or federal grants or apply for a special rate variance.”
There has been little appetite from state and federal governments to transform councils into more responsible and productive ones, with half the councils in NSW and Victoria going backwards financially over the past three years.
An NSW government spokesman said the government had not ordered the report and could not comment on its findings. The state government has provided more than $ 627 million in registered funding for consolidation and infrastructure spending to support the new councils.
“The North Coast Council, for example, is almost doubling its estimated savings from being combined with $ 161.6 million in savings in 10 years,” the spokesman said, adding that the government is committed to strengthening sustainability, efficiency and integrity. Responsibility and transparency of the local government department.
Using audited financial statements published by NSW’s 128 Councils, the LSI has developed a productivity index to measure the operating performance of congregations since 2016, forcing NSW Super Council affiliations.
More than half have gone backwards in that period, using the definition of measuring productivity approved by the Productivity Authority. Analyzing the LSI accounts, the operating losses accumulated in 128 councils were estimated at 1.5 billion billion, excluding state and federal subsidies, which included manuals rather than operating income.
The index measures the output of the councils associated with the input. The publication will measure the services provided by each council in relation to the income they receive from rates, parking fees and other regulatory income. Each council is the input to provide services.
These figures were published exclusively Herald, 19 of the 20 super councils have lost money since the merger and the remaining 108 NSW councils have not been forced to merge.
LSI figures show that of NSW’s 128 councils, eight of the 10 worst performing councils are affiliated councils.
The productivity index of the 20 affiliated 20 councils has fallen 16 percent since the merger, compared to a decline of nearly 1 percent for the remaining 108 NSW councils.
In all, 20 councils reported $ 1.03 billion in operating losses, excluding subsidies, between 2016 and 2019.
The government said during the merger that they would not be laid off for three years and that councils would be given hundreds of millions of dollars in sweets to help with the cost of the merger. However, some councilors said that sweets were not enough to fund the mergers and that the lack of adequate funding was one reason for the poor performance.
According to Bahi of the LSI, the congregations were not given a map or model of how to unite. “There should be improvements after three years, but the statistics do not indicate that.”
The worst-performing council in the NSW is the Base Council, formed from the merger of the Botanical Bay and Rocktail City Councils. It went backwards from its productivity link and lost $ 155.7 million in production losses in three years.
The second worst-performing council in the NSW is the Inner West Council, which was formed from a merger of Marrikville, Leechard and Ashfield Councils, which has lost the equivalent of $ 124 million; It was followed by the Paramatman City Council, which lost $ 113.5 million in productivity; Central Coast, which has lost $ 113 million in productivity in three years, and North Beach, which has lost $ 105 million in productivity.
Bezite has been criticized by residents for spending nearly $ 7 million on a $ 10 million government subsidy on Astroturb for two neighboring parks, which was not raised by anyone in an outsourced community consultation.
“At no time did the community demand or request that the artificial turf be installed in Arncliffe Park or Gardiner Park,” said resident Garnett Brownbill. “It went against the suggestions and advice of advisers due to flooding and other concerns on both sites, and costs have exploded.”
A council spokesman said Gardiner Park was chosen to meet the growing demands of the upgrade community. On the board’s overall financial performance, a spokesman said: “Overall, over the past four fiscal years since consolidation, Basite has received $ 162.5 million (including capital grants and contributions) or $ 17.9 million (excluding capital grants and contributions).”
Mr Bahi denied the council’s figures and said productivity had deteriorated due to the fall in labor and other costs due to the merger.
At the Inner West Council, integration is the integration of three different systems: rates, library services, swimming pools and gyms, waste collection, street cleaning, playground fees and fees, and computer systems.
The council is still implementing three separate rate systems across the local government area, although the state government must synchronize rates before the July 2021 deadline.
The Federal Coastal Council is in financial conflict and said it needs twice as much as the state government has provided.
Announcing the appointment of an executive to the council on Friday, Local Government Minister Shelley Hancock said: “There is a clear need for greater oversight and control over the council’s budget and the costs of restoring its financial stability, and effectively re-establishing the confidence of the community in the functioning of their council.”
Cumberland Council Mayor Steve Cristo described the merger as “a bad deal”. He said the promised savings were not working and the government had not provided enough funds to cover the connection costs.
Cumberland Council ranked seventh worst in the NSW, losing $ 81.6 million from the merger.
Mr. Cristo took a further financial step when the Cumberland government changed borders, removing industrial rates collected from Silverwater and allocating it to Paramatman instead. He said the council has embarked on a major productivity drive and hopes to remain black next year.
Mr Bahi said alarm bells rang for the Central Coast Council ahead of the COVID-19 victory.
The council was formed in 2016 in collaboration with the Wyong and Gosford Councils. The draft interim report presented to the House on October 6 pointed to a budget deficit of $ 89 million, which doubled the expected deficit to $ 41 million. It blamed the cash flow problems of the merger and COVID-19. As investigations continue, there are also signs of financial misappropriation.
Linda Scott, chairwoman of the local council, the supreme body that represents the state’s 128 councils, said the government should step in and address the concerns.
“If this government supports their decision [to force amalgamations], They have a responsibility to support forcibly consolidated councils over the entire 10-year period that their own modeling predicts will take any financial benefit, “Ms Scott said.” A clear and transparent approach to local financial stability The government has now become even more important as the country struggles to recover from the economic downturn of the Govt epidemic. “
Joseph Drew, an expert in local government at the University of Technology in Sydney, said at least half a dozen integrated NSW councils face similar problems to the Central Coastal Council, or were unconnected to the financial crisis of the corona virus crisis.
“I want us to be proactive and provide them with the assistance they need before a catastrophic situation arises. And there are plenty of other danger signs. Councils across Australia are under financial pressure,” he said. “When churches fail, people suffer. A lot of people get hurt where I see this topic.”
The state government’s Strong Communities Fund was intended to accelerate congregations affected by the mergers by providing grants for community projects, but now it is under investigation by the Auditor General and the subject of a parliamentary inquiry into allegations that its $ 250 million grant round was used as a bacon. Parallel tool during the 2019 state election.
Inner West Mayor Darcy Byrne said the government’s promised financial savings from forced consolidation “never worked in any of the integrated councils.”
“Many costly decisions about staffing and information technology were made in the integrated councils after the dismissal of the integrated representatives and the establishment of elected executives of the government,” he said.
“The truth is that the mergers are very expensive and very difficult, and the government should have given full funding to these mergers.
Get our morning and evening edition newsletters
Adele Ferguson is a Gold Wagley Award winning investigative journalist. His reports and comments on companies, markets and the economy.
Angus Thompson is the city affairs correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald.
Megan Corey is the city affairs correspondent for the Sydney Morning Herald.